Student questions and answers

I received a few emails concerning the practice questions:

Q: Are the answers for the multiple choice questions #34 and 38, Ch 8 correct? For #34, the bucket is just being dropped. There is friction and mass is negligable, so I do not understand why the answer isn't 9.8 m/s^2.

A: ??? there is friction? and the mass of the ROPE is negligeable, but it's still attached to the cylinder and crank, which need to be accelerated, all from the weight of the bucket. So the answer must be LESS than 9.8 m/s². I don't think you read the problem carefully. Don't let that happen on the exam!

Q: I also don't see how you get c. 6.5 m/s^2 for #38 when no numbers are given to you.....

A: This of course assumes gravity at 9.8 m/s², else you'd be right, not enough data. But in τ = I α = I (a/R) both τ (from gravity) and I are proportional to m, so m cancels; and you'll find that R also cancels. So the answer is just (factor) × g, where (factor) comes from the expression for I.


Q: Sorry to bother you but I have a question about practice problem #28 from Chapter 6 from the sample exam 2 preparation. The answer key says the correct answer is "D" No answer is correct, but I found a similar problem in the text and student's solution manual that has a similar problem (Chapter 6 end-of-chapter problem #7) where it states the following: "A professional diver performs a dive from a platform 10 m above the water surface. Estimate the order of magnitude of the average impact force she experiences in her collision with the water. State the quantities you take as data and their values."
It then proceeds to use [Fav = m (sqrt(2gh)) / δ t] to solve for the average force. This seems like a similar problem and when I plug in the posted values for #28 on the practice exam I actually get 980N as the answer (c). If you have a moment, could you briefly tell me if I'm missing something else here? The problems seem identical to me...(in the solutions manual they even use 1 sec as the time between impact and coming to rest...)

A:I agree the juxtaposition of these two problems is a bit confusing, since they do seem so similar. The difference is, the practice problem asks for the average force that the water exerts, whereas the book problem asks for the force experienced by the diver. The difference? Gravity also exerts a force, so the force of the water must be that of the diver plus the magnitude of the gravitational force (or minus that force, which is itself negative when up is positive).


Q: I am having issues figuring out #52 and 55 from Ch 5 and #57 and 75 from Ch 8. Can you please help?

A: From free-fall you know the energy with which it strikes. This is dissipated by the resistive force from the ground AND by gravity (the latter being "negative dissipation"), which you know; so that total force x the unkown distance = KE you calculated in the first part. No one tells you the mass of the post, so one must assume that negligible.
For 55, use work-energy. The initial potential energy becomes work of friction (20 N x 100 m) + final energy. The latter gives you the speed.
8.57: contemplate ½Iw². I is proportional to M, so for the second flywheel is half. w is doubled, so w² is 4 x as big. Makes an overall factor of 2. Again, 106 should be 10^6. 8.75: This one spells trouble. I think they want you to work it by conservation of angular momentum, but actually K.E. and hence speed is conserved. So it's either always or never 5 m/s. (Where would the energy come from to increase the ball's speed?)


Q: I've been working on the webassign and there is one problem I cannot get even though I've been working on it for a few hours and even asked a few classmates. If you could help me it would be greatly appreciated:

Question:
A large 5.0 kg hoop of radius 3.0 m rolls without slipping. If the hoop is given an angular speed of 3.5 rad/s while rolling on the horizontal and allowed to roll up a ramp inclined at 30° with the horizontal, how far (measured along the incline) does the hoop roll?
So I formed the equation:

(1/2)mrω² + (1/2)mr²ω² = mgLsin(30)
And then I solved for L (i choose L to be the length along the incline). What am I doing wrong?

A: What are you doing wrong, you ask? One error is obvious even if you know nothing about the problem but just look at the equation: it's dimensionally wrong! Is that enough to let you solve it correctly?